The Trailer for 'Scrooge: A Christmas Carol' is the Oddest Musical Version This Year

Growing up, there were three truths about the holidays. Jo is right: Christmas won't be Christmas without any presents, the Grinch's heart would grow three sizes, and Scrooge will go from asking, "Are there no workhouses?" to buying a turkey the size of Tiny Tim. While the first two of those, Little Women and The Grinch Who Stole Christmas, only get remade once a decade or so, A Christmas Carol gets new variations just about every year. This year, there are two coming to theaters before landing on streaming, but of them, it's the British-made one that takes the cake for originality.

The American one, Spirited, stars Ryan Reynolds, who lately has been leaning into the anglophilic side of his Canadian upbringing, buying Wrexham's football team and turning it into a Ted Lasso-inspired reality series, Welcome to Wrexham. It looks appropriately jollied up and modernized for American audiences. It has been turned into a musical, co-starring Will Ferrell, who will forever be remembered for his modern Christmas classic, Elf.

But the British offering, Scrooge: A Christmas Carol, goes one better. This story retelling is far more traditional, though it also leans into being a musical. However, it's also a supernatural, time-traveling, animated musical adaptation of the classic story. Sorry, Ryan Reynolds, but I think this will win in the head-to-head of which of these to stream Christmas morning.